French and French-language Films, German and German-language Films, Northern European Films

Fatherland: an exploration of Europe in a political / cultural borderland

Pawel Pawlikowski, “Fatherland” (2026)

A reimagination of German writer Thomas Mann’s return to Germany in 1949, after sixteen years living in the United States, “Fatherland” explores Europe in a political / cultural borderland between World War II, just ended, and the Cold War, just beginning. This sense of being caught between two unenviable periods of history, with all their poisonous ideologies and the destruction they brought, is reflected in the lives of Mann and his daughter Erika as they travel from Frankfurt in Allied-occupied Germany to Weimar in Soviet-occupied Germany in mid-1949. (In real life, Mann and his wife had travelled to Weimar but having the daughter travel with the father instead, along with other liberties director / co-scriptwriter Pawlikowski took, opens up other possibilities to investigate other forms of transition, physical and non-physical.)

In the summer of 1949, Erika (Sandra Huller), living in the US, receives a phone call from her brother Klaus (August Diehl), living in Cannes, who complains about the state of contemporary art and is unhappy about his own writing. Erika invites Klaus to come to Germany and join her and their father Thomas (Hanns Zischler) on a trip to Frankfurt where Thomas will receive the Goethe Prize. Klaus says he’ll think about joining. Erika and Thomas subsequently travel to Frankfurt where they attend a press conference, at which Thomas is told he will receive a second Goethe Prize in Weimar. Some reporters warn Thomas that visiting Soviet-occupied Germany will expose him to accusations of Communist sympathies but Thomas reminds his audience that Goethe and German literature existed before the separation of Germany and that art and literature transcend politics and political borders.

After the ceremony in which Thomas receives the first prize, he and Erika attend the reception where two grandsons of Richard Wagner ask Thomas if he will support the rehabilitation of the Bayreuth Festival; Thomas not only refuses but says the whole festival should be razed to the ground. Erika is accosted by her ex-husband (Joachim Meyerhoff), who had enjoyed the patronage of Hermann Goering during Nazi rule; the two quarrel and Erika smacks him. She returns to her room to discover news that Klaus has committed suicide. On being informed of the news, Thomas insists that their trip to Weimar should go ahead and they should start as soon as possible the following morning.

The two drive to Weimar, along part of the way which they are accompanied by cultural officials of the new Soviet-affiliated regime in eastern Germany and treated to a program of various events including several banquets, army choirs and a children’s choir, all designed to impress Thomas and to entice him into supporting the culture of the new East Germany. Thomas receives his second Goethe Prize and gives a speech. Erika is bored by all these events and stays away from most of them, preferring instead to wander around their hotel or to mull and grieve over Klaus’s death in her hotel room. Eventually when they have to return to Frankfurt, they dutifully follow their escort but stop at a bombed-out church to walk amongst its ruins and watch two men repair and tune an organ. The men play part of Johann Sebastian Bach’s “Jesu, Joy of Man’s Desiring” and Thomas and Erika sit and listen.

There’s plenty of heartbreak and grief at Klaus’s passing, even though much of that emotion is suppressed and only released at the very end, and what his passing may mean for Thomas and Erika alike. Klaus may represent a wasted talent, one gone all too soon with little to show for it, a talent sorely needed by a Europe in reconstruction, and that reconstruction likely to head in a direction just as unstable and potentially dangerous and deadly as its previous direction was. In the twilight of his career, Thomas is out of place in the new post-war world and his views of what Germany could or should be look quaint and unrealistic in a more cut-throat world divided between avaricious American-dominated capitalism and paranoid authoritarian Soviet Communism. Erika herself is critical of Nazism and Communism, but (like Thomas) is unhappy about political, social and cultural developments heading towards Senator Joseph McCarthy’s anti-Communist hysteria and the repressions that would follow in the Mann family’s adopted homeland in the US.

While the acting is very good – Huller as always is superb, this time in her guarded pensiveness – and the cinematography is sharp, with static images, the film suffers from a short runtime that limits character development and reduces its historical context to almost nil. We don’t find out why Erika is devoted to her father and why Thomas’s wife Katia never appears or gets a mention. Much of the emotion and grief at loss in the film is what may be expected, to the point of being banal; what else would be expected of Erika and Thomas when they hear that Klaus has committed suicide? That Erika and Thomas react in different ways might reflect the difference between their generations and the environments they grew up in – that’s hardly an original observation. Thomas’s stubborn decision to continue on to Weimar after the news might strike some viewers as callous and cruel, or as an example of outdated traditions about struggling on in the face of tragedy; and Erika’s refusal to be part of a propaganda circus in Weimar, even as her father goes along with it, looks rather petulant. There could be better ways of resisting being turned into puppets for the new East German government, but Pawlikowski and co-writer Hendrik Handloegten miss them all.

The best part of the film comes at the very end, where the ruined church’s environment offers a beautiful and spiritually comforting place free of ideologies and politics that exploit, punish and oppress artists and intellectuals for their own ends, and where Thomas and Erika can finally accept Klaus’s death. That the church offers temporary comfort and peace only in its ruined form, free of the ideologies that created it, is an irony that would not be lost on the recipients.